2019 Newbery Medal: Merci Suárez Changes Gears by Meg Medina

Merci Suárez Changes Gears, by Meg Medina, was published in 2018 by Candlewick.

Rating: 3/5

I loved Meg Medina’s Burn Baby Burn, a YA book that dealt with a tough (and rarely discussed) topic. So I was interested to see how her foray into MG would be like, especially since it won the Newbery Medal. My verdict? Merci Suárez Changes Gears is disappointingly average.

It lacks some oomph, some sparkle, some sort of thing that would make it so much better than it is. Maybe the writing needed to be jazzed up. Maybe the platitudes and the cheesy way the book ended helped to keep it weighed down in “mediocre” territory. It’s not that the topic wasn’t relevant, or that the book was boring. It was simply missing…something.

I did appreciate the more nuanced sort of look at school troubles that Medina gave, though. I do have to give her credit for creating a realistic school atmosphere, and a more realistic look at bullying. I myself had way more experience with bullies who were friendly one day and mean the next, rather than the “I have a personal vendetta against you” bully that is so often portrayed, so I felt Medina’s take was much more reflective of what actually occurs, showing how navigating friendships and other people is complicated, especially in the tumultuous preteen and teen years.

However, that does leave me wondering as to why no one ever writes a story from the bully’s point of view. Where are all the books about the Ednas? Why does no author bother to tackle that sort of challenge?

Anyway, Merci Suárez Changes Gears doesn’t break out of any boxes or push any boundaries in terms of writing conventions or tropes. It’s a disappointing book, one that could have been much better with just a little something extra added to it to truly make it shine.

Recommended Age Range: 8+

Warnings: None.

Genre: Children’s, Realistic

You can buy this book here: https://amzn.to/2Iz69AP

Burn Baby Burn by Meg Medina

Burn Baby Burn, by Meg Medina, was published in 2016 by Candlewick.

Nora Lopez is seventeen during the infamous year 1977 in New York. After a freezing winter, a boiling hot summer explodes with arson, a blackout, and a serial killer named Son of Sam, who is shooting young people on the street seemingly at random. Not only is the city a disaster, but Nora has troubles of her own: her brother, Hector, is growing more uncontrollable by the day, her mother is helpless to stop him, and her father is so busy with his new family that he only calls on holidays. And it doesn’t stop there. The super’s after her mother to pay their overdue rent and her teachers are pushing her to apply for college, but all Nora wants is to turn eighteen and be on her own. There is a cute guy who started working with her at the deli, but is dating even worth the risk when the killer especially likes picking off couples who stay out too late?

Rating: 5/5

I kinda loved Burn Baby Burn and I’m not sure why. At least, I’m not sure why the presence of things I don’t like in contemporary young adult literature didn’t make me instantly hate the book. Maybe it was the historical aspect of it, the tension as a result of Son of Sam and the 1977 blackout that resulted in the largest mass arrest in history (3,776). I don’t think I could have ignored the content if it hadn’t been for the historical fiction aspect. Or maybe it was the depiction of juvenile domestic violence, which Medina states in her author’s note as a “chronically underreported issue,” a depiction that made me sit up and say, “Why isn’t this mentioned more often?” Whatever it was, I devoured this book and got lost in the pages.

Most of all, I think this book reminded me of some of the reasons why I used to read contemporary young adult literature (until I finally got sick of all the negative and destructive images and ideas). Good YA lit. is powerful. It packs a punch and takes no prisoners. It’s not afraid to depict the least-heard-of in society, the hard times, the pivotal moments in our history relayed through the eyes of someone who is not ourselves. And yes, there’s bad content in it, and yes, it’s aggravating (at least for me) to read such casual mentions of something that should not be casual at all, but it somehow gripped me anyway—and that’s the mark of a good story.

Burn Baby Burn is not for everyone. But it’s certainly a book that can be read and discussed and raises important questions, especially in reference to domestic violence. It’s also great for its historical aspect alone, which is, now that I think about it, probably the reason I loved it so much. Historical fiction, especially young adult historical fiction, is a great genre, and Burn Baby Burn fits rights in.

Recommended Age Range: 16+

Warnings: Domestic violence, drug abuse, arson, murder, sexual situations, swearing.

Genre: Historical Fiction, Young Adult

 “The whole city is going crazy! And your hermanito is out there.” Her jaw quivers. “Did he take a coat?”

“I don’t remember.”

“What if something happened and he’s cold? What if he doesn’t have spare change to call home?”

I ignore her.

“And what is his fascination with this screaming music? Why are a bunch of grown men yelling and jumping like that, anyway?”

Pass.

I turn up the TV and pretend to concentrate as the news drones on. I can’t stop thinking about this girl’s rag-doll body, the police standing over her, the strange angle of those stylish boots. I’m thinking of the decoy cops who might be sitting down the block right now.

Maybe I should be worried.

You can buy this here: http://amzn.to/2aAeWy1